I had thought about the possible battledolphin/hydro duo, with hydro being responsible for the night 1 kill AND the second kill breaking my protection on aero, if there is no strongman. But doesn't joat have one shot of each ability usually? As for hydro and myself being mafia, that doesn't make any sense. If there is no SK then me being mafia doctor makes no sense, and you wouldn't have a joat as well as a doctor as the mafia. A joat and an odd-night doctor both being mafia would be a weird and weak team.
A hydro/battledolphin or maybe hydro/maribro could work, but a hydro/myself or hydro/ghostbone duo wouldn't make much sense.
You getting Vanilla from BD and Maribro, joat from hydro, doctor from myself and yourself being a role cop. That means that assuming all of your role cop claims have been correct, the possible combinations are:
BD and hydro - Vanilla + JOAT
BD and Ghostbone - Vanilla + Role cop
Maribro and hydro - Vanilla + JOAT
Maribro and Ghostbone - Vanilla + Role cop
Ghostbone and Hydro - Cop + JOAT
Considering that a standard JOAT is one-shot of each, hydro could not be the one who made the 2nd kill night 1 AND broke protection against aero. It must be a strongman
Which leaves the possibilities of: BD and Ghostbone - Anything + role cop
Maribro and Ghostbone - Anything + role cop
Ghostbone and Hydro - role cop + anything. Hydro can claim JOAT and then you confirm that he is as role cop.
I don't think it can be BD and Hydro or Maribro and Hydro. The only possible way for Hydro to be mafia is if JOAT was a fake role that he made up and you confirmed.
Myself and Hydro as JOAT makes no sense. Myself and BD or Maribro as vanilla does not explain how there were two kills on two nights (or the alternative of two kills on one night and a strongman on the aero night).
Could JOAT in theory be a 1-shot strongman?
If so, that explains how there was the 2nd kill first night and the breaking of protection with the aero very well.
Ghost + BD or Ghost + Maribro doesn't explain that nearly as well.
unless Hydro bluffed about not using his shot,when it was actually used night 1. and BD or Maribro is instead the strongman.
But why not say so?