Traitors aren't picked up by gunsmith tho. Or would dean have stated it if there was a traitor?
Looked it up and it looks like a traitor doesn't need to be stated (but mafia still needs to know there's one). It'd make sense as 4th or (more likely) a 5th mafia member to balance things
Also, here's each day's votes; with people who are still alive in bold.
Final vote count for Day 1:
ThatLaggyPerson (11) - cAKE, Aerodrome, BastyTho,
SpaceJam, BattleDolphin, Windkeeper0, EIS-DUON, Ghostbone, Dyna_Hole,
AutumnWind (1) - LachlanF
LachlanF (1) - MrL
Corvid (1) - InsertName
Not voted (6) - HydroPimp,
Corvid, Maribro, AutumnWind
Aerodrome (2) - Dyna_Hole,
Invisi (3) - SpaceJam, Ghostbone, BastyTho
LachlanF (10) - Aerodrome,
Invisi, cAKE, cjeccjec, EIS-DUON, InsertName, Windkeeper0, MrL,
Not voted (3) - HydroPimp,
Aerodrome (5) - Maribro, AutumnWind
, Rhyno, Insertname, cjeccjec
Maribro (8) - Aerodrome,
Invisi, Ghostbone, MrL, HydroPimp, Windkeeper0, cAKE, BastyTho
Not voted (2) - Dyna_Hole, EIS-DUON
Interestingly, only 3 people have voted for the person who was lynched each day, who are still alive.
cAKE, Aero and Windkeeper.
The first two days, cAKE and Aero were aggressive voters, voting close together (Aero being the starter of 2 bandwagons and the follower of 1 [first to follower].
Windkeeper on the other hand has joined each bandwagon later on, being one of the last to vote for each lynch.
I'd imagine it'd be a pretty safe tactic to try and have mafia vote on opposite ends of the bandwagon. Aero and cAKE are more aggresive players than Wind, which would make for an interesting mix of playstyles for a mafia team.
Also it'd be safe to assume that especially with laggy being lynch #1, all of the mafia members could join the bandwagon with 100% safety; even aero's survived this far with being very aggressive about it.
For this reason, I think it'd be safe to assume that Hydro, CJ, Autumnwind, Insert and I are less likely to be mafia. Why waste the opportunity of a free kill and night phase?
Windkeeper, cAKE and Basty all voting within a small timeframe and quickhammering Maribro is another thing to note.
Assuming there is a traitor to fill out mafia numbers - my two guesses would be Duon or Basty. But there's not much for that.
Basty made a very traitor-y play with the quickhammer, especially after wind and cake voted; made no sense, came out of the blue, was scummy, but could be passed off as a gaff or inexperience, while still sending a strong signal to mafia.
Duon being much more aggressive in day 4 than in other days, suggesting players reveal roles? could be palmed off as a 'might as well suggest something' but also a strong (but weaker signal) to mafia that he could be a traitor.
There's more of a case for Basty than Duon, but Duon would definitely be the more dangerous player so we should be cautious moving forward.